Human Rights Vs. Individual Rights Vs. Fundamental Rights

Human Rights Vs. Individual Rights Vs. Fundamental Rights

WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS AND FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS?

England's constitution is unwritten. As a result, there is no such code of fundamental rights in England as there is in the United States constitution or other written constitutions around the world. This does not, however, imply that England does not recognise the fundamental human rights that democracy would be meaningless without. Individual rights in England are derived from Parliamentary common law. 
 
In England, as elsewhere, the judiciary is the guardian of individual rights; however, there is a significant difference. While the courts in England have broad powers to protect individuals from executive tyranny, they are powerless to protect individuals from legislative violations of their rights. In short, the legislature in England is not bound by any fundamental rights.
UPSC Prelims 2024 dynamic test series
Because the English parliament is theoretically 'omnipotent,' it can change any law. This is because, as previously stated, the English people's individual rights are derived from ordinary law, which, like other laws, can be changed by Parliament, and nothing prevents the English Parliament from doing so (Parliamentary Supremacy). As a result, there are no fundamental rights in England in the strict sense of the term. Another consequence of parliamentary supremacy is that English courts are unable to declare any law passed by the English parliament null and void on the basis of alleged fundamental or individual rights being violated.
 
In contrast to the English situation, the Bill of Rights in the United States is a true set of fundamental rights. They bind both the legislature and the executive branch equally. If a law passed by Congress violates any of the rights guaranteed by the American Bill of Rights, the American judiciary has the power to declare it null and void. 
 
The fundamental difference in approach to the issue of individual rights between England and the United States is that, while the English were concerned about executive power abuses, the framers of the American constitution were concerned about tyranny not only from the executive but also from the legislature—that is, a group of men who, for the time being, form the majority in the legislature. As a result, we can deduce that in England, only individual rights exist, whereas in the United States, fundamental rights exist.
 

Human Rights Vs. Individual Rights Vs. Fundamental Rights

WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS AND HUMAN RIGHTS?

'Rights,' in general, refers to a moral or legal claim to something. According to the law, rights are defined as an individual's reasonable claim that is accepted by society and legislated. It could be either fundamental or human rights. Fundamental rights are those rights that are essential to a country's citizens' daily lives. Human rights, on the other hand, refer to the rights that all human beings have regardless of their nationality, race, caste, creed, gender, or other factors.
 
The primary distinction between fundamental rights and human rights is that fundamental rights are limited to a single country, whereas human rights are universally recognised.
 

BASIS FOR COMPARISON

FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS

HUMAN RIGHTS

Meaning

Fundamental Rights means the primary rights of the citizens which are justifiable and written in the constitution.

Human Rights are the basic rights that all the human beings can enjoy, no matter where they live, what they do, and how they behave, etc.

Includes

Basic Rights Only

Basic and Absolute Rights

Scope

It is country specific.

It is universal.

Basic Principle

Right of freedom

Right of life with dignity

Guarantee

Constitutionally guaranteed

Internationally guaranteed

Enforcement

Enforceable by the court of law.

Enforceable by United Nation Organization.

Origin

Originated from the views of democratic society.

Originated from the ideas of civi­lized nations.

Any suggestions or correction in this article - please click here ([email protected])

Related Posts: